Skip to main content

Tip Jar

Syracuse sex abuse scandal: Who should you believe?

Jim Boheim, Syracuse head coach and Bernie Fine,
associate head coach. (l-r) from

First there was the travesty of Penn State, a college football super there is the storied Syracuse University basketball program.  Bobby Davis and his step brother Mike Lang, claim that an associate head coach for Syracuse sexually molested them for over a decade, with Bobby suffering the most.

Bobby first brought these allegations forward in 2003, before the Penn State situation was made public.  He went to the police and they investigated, saying they needed a corroborating witness in order to pursue the case.  Mr. Davis gave them four witnesses, who would not back up his claims.

So, he was turned away.  Well, recently his stepbrother stood up, and said it happened to him as well.  It sounds shaky, no doubt.  The Syracuse head coach claims it is all being said for money!  There is no way his associate could have done that.  He never saw him do more than touch a kid on the shoulder.

Bobby Davis tells ESPN that he wants no money.  He wants nothing from his alleged abuser, other than to tell the truth, for the accused to get help, and to stop it from happening to anyone else.  The stepbrothers, according to ESPN, had only spoken three times in the last eight years.

When it first came out in 2003, Mr. Lang didn't want to talk about it.  He would only admit that the coach touched his leg inappropriately and refused to say anything else.

When the Penn State story broke, Mr. Davis contacted his stepbrother, emotionally distraught, and said it was happening all over again and he wanted it to stop.  So according to the ESPN reporter, Mr. Lang finally broke down emotionally and admitted that he was molested, and asked his brother who should he contact.

The ESPN reporter received a tearful call from Mr. Lang, telling him that he was in fact molested by the Syracuse associate head coach more than a dozen times.

What makes sex crimes so hard to prosecute is that it usually boils down to who you believe.  Absent any physical traces of the offense, you are left to focus on the credibility of the witnesses and any circumstantial evidence that remains.

All too often, people choose to believe the accused versus the accuser.  Why? Well the accused rarely seems like he/she would ever do anything contrary to the norm.  So the bystanders usually utter the words "I've known so and so for years, he/she would never do anything like that." That's what makes it so easy for abusers to continue in their terror.

This is especially true in molestation and child sex abuse cases.  No one WANTS to believe that someone would harm a child.  No one wants to believe that an "upstanding" and "righteous" man or woman would ever have sexual desires and contact with a child.  That's how they get away with it. Molesters are usually people who work closely with children.  People who have "hearts of gold", as Jerry Sandusky was described to the mother of Victim 1.

It is hard to believe an abuse victim.  Typically they are pretty messed up.  They are insecure and many suffer from post traumatic stress disorder.  Their stories "change", because often they have blocked out portions of what happened in order to cope.  Then at times they reveal bits and pieces as they grow more secure in letting it all out.

And then the social stigmas placed on those who suffer at the hands of someone of the same sex abusing them, magnifies the situation.  Little boys don't want to tell that a man has touched them "in THAT way".  People will call them names like "sissy" and "fag" and do everything to tear at an already shattered core.

No one ever believes a woman would abuse a child sexually.  Look at how they react to the teacher-student sex scandals.  Not understanding that sex abuse is not about gender.  It is about the harmful keeping of secrets.  It is also the ravaging of the psyche.  Domestic terrorism is a good way to look at it.

Abuse victims live in fear.  They are torn apart.  Because of the relationship the person has with the accused abuser, the victim lives in a double self state of mind.  They may even love the abuser because of things that happen outside of the abuse.  So they are torn...mentally anguished while publicly coping in order to keep that dirty secret.

Abusers are charismatic, cunning, secretive, and demented.  They wow and woo, then sadistically destroy. You cannot look at someone and tell that they are an abuser.  You can know someone for years without realizing what they do when you're not around.  That is how they become so prolific.  Most pedophiles have dozens of victims if not a hundred or more.

These labels of someone being "good" or "bad" do a disservice to those who may suffer at the hands of a person labeled "good".  There's no such thing.  People are not "good".  People are not "bad".  People are people, who do good or bad.

So yes it is very possible that  Bernie Fine, the Syracuse associate head coach who is under investigationcommitted the very crimes of which he is accused.  For Jim Boheim to speak out in the way he has, does a disservice to other abuse victims.  Sure, stand up for your friend.  By all means.  But what you should never do is speak for someone else's proclivities.

A simple, "no comment" would suffice.  What happens if it is proven that Bernie Fine molested the two men who are speaking out publicly?  What happens if there are more who were abused by him?  What say you then?

Certainly it is difficult when someone is falsely accused of such things.  But never say what another person would not do.   Trust would be surprised...

Popular posts from this blog

A Sense of Safety (Guest Post)

February is Teen Dating Violence Awareness Month. Many young adult DV relationships begin during the teen years. When involved in a DV relationship, a person's safety is very often in peril. Nora Hood guest blogs for YBBG in this post.
A Sense of Safety: Protection or Survivors of Domestic Violence.
Approximately 20,000 calls are made to the National Census of Domestic Violence Services every day. It’s a fact of life for domestic violence survivors who live in fear that a former partner will show up without warning, seeking revenge. Unfortunately, the vast majority of victims haven’t prepared a plan of action, or had security or monitoring devices installed. Protection is a major concern in light of the fact that three women are killed by a partner every day. Providing for your safety and that of your children can seem an overwhelming objective for domestic violence victims who are just trying to get away from destructive relationships and get on with their lives. Many assume that…

Guy Secrets: He treats his friends better than you

I know, the title of this blog post may have caused a screw face with some of you. However...many women often complain about how much time their men spends with friends.
There's a reason for that... If your man spends more time away from you and with his friends... It's because he likes them and feels obligated to you.
That may seem a little crazy, but someone really can love you, but not like you very much. If your relationship is more like a chore than a good me, your dude will always look for an escape. He will take on more hours at his real job, join an extra rec league, hand out with his boys more, etc.
There is a cure for that, though... If you and your boo have a genuine friendship...enjoy similar activities, can talk and joke with each other, really find joy in each other's personalities...he will actually want to spend time with you.
More than that, when a dude considers you a friend, he feels more free and less tied down. Honestly, dudes secretly de…

Curves Connect: Online dating for real people seeking real relationships

Many people find online dating frustrating. Between the lies and game playing, the fear of being "catfished" and the sensory overload they have decided that online dating is a waste of time. Others see online dating as no different than traditional dating and actually feel it is more convenient. Where do you fall within these two contrasting perspectives?